43 Comments

McCarthy was after political gain, and he wasn't interested who suffered from it. As a consequence, he ruined the lives and careers of people in multiple industries and distorted what the meaning of "communism" was in such a way that it belied its original intention.

Trump is more about his own personal benefit. He has successfully conned many people into thinking he knows best when he doesn't, in such numbers that people assume his returning to power is a self-fulfilling prophecy. But deny him media attention and his threat will be reduced.

The media is at fault for taking these things seriously when they don't merit it and not having the institutional means to call it out anymore. We still need the Joseph Welch types to do that, but where to find them in the bowels of the Internet?

Expand full comment
author

All true. But where to find the Joseph Welch types? There are hundreds of them out there, big and small. They need exposure. They need validation. They need support. We can do that. We have the numbers.

Expand full comment
Jan 21Liked by Ramona Grigg

Thank you for so eloquently stating this monumental issue that breaks my heart and reduces me to hopelessness and tears. Thank you for the release I'm experiencing with your written words of shared

shock and overwhelm with the state of affairs. We are decent and cruelty can not and should not be tolerated. Thank you for the shot of strength to not give up.

Expand full comment
author
Jan 22·edited Jan 31Author

It is overwhelming and demoralizing, I know. When I feel that way I write, but I know, even as I'm doing this, it won't make a bit of difference. Not on a larger scale, not in the long run. It's a band aid, a fist-bump, at best. But it's something. And a lot of somethings put together sometimes have an effect. It's what I hope for. It's why I keep on doing this. I wish I could do more.

Expand full comment

Well stated. So true. The azzholes are in the ascendency.

Expand full comment
author

They are. It's up to the rest of us to finally figure out that trying to be friends with them is how we got here in the first place.

Expand full comment
Jan 21Liked by Ramona Grigg

I could not love this more and Lisa has said how I feel in my heart too

Expand full comment
Jan 21Liked by Ramona Grigg

Thank you, Ramona. “Decency needs the upper hand.” I love that and so true. As I was reading I was remembering the times I got called out for being “snarky” or unkind by teachers or my mom, growing up. It stopped the behavior. Made me accountable. And when I raised my kids, I hope I made an effort to do that for them, letting them know how their actions/words affected others, and describing how best to handle similar situations going forward. I don’t see a lot of that kind of discipline very regularly and it concerns me. And having had a selfish, cruel ex-president who modeled infinite cruelty, it seems as if any moral compass is a thing of the past... for some. I do think most people are truly decent, dare I say, moral. But so much damage has been done. It will take a long time, I’m afraid, to restore decency as the everyday standard. I think if each of us centered on the microcosm, our immediate environments, demanding accountability and decency, as you say, it will be our world eventually. The Tr*mps and Abbotts of the world will be called out as bullies more quickly and not tolerated and go back under the rocks they came from. Well, that’s the world I’m envisioning, dreaming of. We are the majority. We just need to move out of exhaustion and despair. I spend everyday visualizing that. It sustains me. Thank you for your beautiful piece. It needed to be said.

Expand full comment
author

Ah, yes, that moral compass... If only...

My piece here is about decency. Someone else's will be about morality. Still others will write about ethics, or the rule of law, or the need for civility. And we'll find some comfort in all of them, knowing they're really pretty meaningless when it comes to any real action that will end or at least diminish cruelty.

That's the hard part. Knowing we're powerless without real power behind us, and so far there is no real power willing to take on cruelty. In fact, cruelty is protected. So-called 'free speech' laws give them latitude to threaten and hurt and destroy, and those who thrive on cruelty take full advantage.

So here we are.

Expand full comment

I live the title. You aren’t alone 🇺🇸💙

Expand full comment
Jan 21·edited Jan 22Liked by Ramona Grigg

I love the idea of demanding decency, though I'm unsure what it looks like in practice. Demanding anything, even as a parent raising my own children, often seems to result in resentment and backlash. Maybe I'm not giving myself or my kids enough credit. For sure, I set boundaries and enacted consequences when lines were crossed, which I think is what you're calling for, on a national scale. I believe my kids are decent humans now. Do the two things have anything to do with each other? One would presume, but then I consider kids who go completely off the rails, despite careful, thoughtful parenting.

You know me, Mona (I think, anyway). I'm always standing in solidarity with anything rooted in kindness and more equitable distributions of power. But I'm also the one looking for the "how." If I already think of myself as decent, because I've determined that my actions are for the common good, what is there for me to do? (It's worth noting that many of those those we think of as INdecent probably believe they are doing it for the greater good.)

Time and again, I've visited the issue of our nation's division in my mind, feeling mostly disempowered to ever really change anything. The only tool I keep coming back to that I feel I can work with consistently and that I want to believe can have an impact in my own community is civil discourse. I'm not sure if we could substitute the word "civil" for "decency," but they are clearly related.

Where I live, we have a regular forum called "Conversations on Race" that I'm making an effort to attend. I think other organizations and agencies could launch those kinds of events (libraries often champion this kind of thing) to give people from all walks of life more likelihood of seeing each other as whole, complex individuals worthy of respect.

https://www.ala.org/tools/sites/ala.org.tools/files/content/LTC_ConvoGuide_final_062414.pdf

Expand full comment
author

Yeah, demanding decency is never going to work, but insisting on consequences just might. You're right that it's the way we get our kids to understand why they don't always get their way. They learn decency by seeing what decency looks like, and feeling what it feels like. The hard part is having to teach them to look out for those others who refuse to buy into it and go the bully route instead.

Again, if there were consistent consequences for bullies that lesson would be much easier to teach. There aren't, and we fail when we throw up our hands and give up. I think that's where we are now. We're having to rethink our own attitudes on cruelty and now we're trying to figure out how to address it. We know we can't keep ignoring it and we have to stop accepting it. That's clearly not working.

So maybe talking about it, hashing it out, calling it what it is might at least be a start. We really need to start.

Expand full comment

Consistency is a conundrum. And I agree that we have to persist, keep looking for ways where we can make meaningful contributions. I'm all in for discussion! I'm all in for listening for understanding! If there's anything I can point to as a consistent culprit for the division we now experience it is that we have more opportunity, now, to "communicate" without ever talking.

Expand full comment

Your caption at the top of the page is an essay in itself. I think you’re right in answering Elizabeth Beggins: One thing decency means in practice is applying consequences. Like parents, judges with Trump in their courtrooms need to anticipate his behavior and have consequences he won’t like ready in advance. They’ll be needed.

Expand full comment
author
Jan 21·edited Jan 21Author

Isn't it crazy that the judges haven't thought of that themselves?

Just crazy...

Expand full comment

Any day now, judges! (Hope)

Expand full comment

Oh my God, Ramona! What an eloquent post and plea for dignity and kindness.

I know Australia is very far from perfect and I probably have no right at all to comment.

But I'm gobsmacked at Texas, at Iowa, at MAGA supporters. I read today of Trump's confusion at the NH rallies where he mistakenly, repeatedly, called Haley Pelosi and his mistake was accepted (and no doubt lauded).

I shudder every time he gains a step on the ladder. As I think does the rest of the western world. America has lost its fine international cachet. It's only its armoury other nations want, not its decent free-speech and valour. People outside of the States laugh at Trump and then shake their heads at the thought that an idiot will have his finger on the button. I would say they feel trepidation but that gives the bully power and we don't want to give Trump any more power.

My heart goes out to all decent, kind Americans of all persuasions and I hope they get out and vote with foresight for their nation when the time comes.

Mind you, I hoped the same here and whilst we had a change from conservative government, the Labour Party (read Democrat) has done little.

Expand full comment
author

It's a growing problem with no end in sight. All we can do, I guess, is spell it out. Try to appeal to a more responsible crowd who at some point may just come up with answers that seem to be beyond the rest of us.

I mean, we reward cruelty. Or at least we don't condemn it. Not in any meaningful way. I wish words alone would work. They won't. They never will.

Expand full comment
Jan 21Liked by Ramona Grigg

Hi Mona,

Loved this…you are always spot on!

Up here, we have already accepted that, the Republican Party, in general, is operating under the guise of…”CRUELTY IS the OBJECTIVE”! The rhetoric and their actions prove there is NO longer ANY illusion! Decency seems to be old-fashioned and out-dated. We are completely disgusted by their behaviour and continue to hope that KARMA will visit them sooner, rather than later. Those who use religion as a prop, are particularly vile, while they totally and pointedly, ignore the teachings of Jesus Christ. We, too, keep hoping for a miracle…that the orange moron will just disappear from the face of the earth…and take his MAGA buddies with him! In the meantime, we are holding our breath…we are ultimately convinced that there are MORE good and decent people within the borders of the U.S.A., than there are followers, of the criminal former president! We are watching and hoping!

❤️ ❤️🇨🇦🇨🇦

Expand full comment
author

Thanks, Kathy. I don't know why we don't spend more time here highlighting decency rather than cruelty. We know every cruel move by Trump and his underlings, and all it does is normalize cruelty. The press thrives on making cruelty interesting.

It seriously has to change.

Expand full comment

I am appalled at some of the cruel things I read and hear about these days. I sincerely hope you are right about decency winning. In my mind, it went out the door the day Donald Trump walked down that escalator to say he was running for president. All the things he has said and done that no one has called him on it - or if they do it is overridden. I wonder if he knows the meaning of the word decency.

Expand full comment
author

We don't give enough negative attention to cruelty. It's treated now like benign entertainment, and I'll never understand it. When Kyle Rittenhouse went free after killing two protestors and then went on to become a strutting, grinning celebrity thanks to the MAGA crowd, I really began to panic. But that's just one example. We have Trump people like Roger Stone on tape saying two Democratic House members must DIE, and the fuss is hardly an uproar.

It goes on and on, I could be here all day showing examples, but we all know what they are and who they are. It's not as if we're just now discovering secrets. We've been living with a growing list of godawful, real life examples of the worst kind of cruelty for decades and we still don't have a handle on how to deal with it. Don't even get me started on assault weapons!

Expand full comment

Just when I think I have seen the worst of people - something else happens to lower the bar. And yes - there are assault weapons. Somehow, I don't think the 2nd amendment had them in mind..

Expand full comment

Norms, rules, decency, even politeness, seems to have gone out the window. It's enraging. I'd love to be able to shame people (giving them consequences for terrible behavior) but how do you shame the shameless? When I tried to shame Ted Cruz during a "town hall" (long story), he just cut and run. It didn't change his behavior one bit. Now he's even joking about him taking his family to Cancun when the rest of us were freezing. No shame.

The problems here are myriad. Many have (rightfully) called out the media for highlighting awful behavior that brings in readers and the judicial system is too broken to make any meaningful headway. It's always about money. Texas has been so dreadfully gerrymandered that the people in power can do whatever they want without fear; the only people they need to please are the billionaires. Greg Abbott is playing to a very small group: the billionaires who fund him and his allies (which is why Ken Paxton wasn't convicted in the state senate) and I suspect Trump. Abbott knows he'd never be elected to higher office on his own, so he's getting it however he can. The cruelty at the border is to suck up to Trump. It's infuriating.

I wish I knew how to change things, especially in Texas, but I don't. God knows I've tried. But we can't stop trying. I appreciate your words, Ramona, and am glad you keep reminding us what we need to fight for.

Expand full comment
author

I know what you mean, Misty. I'm frustrated by the fact that some people just can't be shamed. It's not as if we don't work at shaming them. Nobody has been made more fun of than Donald Trump, yet here he is, a notoriously deviant, unconscionable criminal getting ready to exact revenge on all of us if he ever gets back into the White House--and he's far and away his party's front-runner.

Cruel, hateful people get off on our complaints. Nothing pleases them more than a sure sign that the buttons they've pushed are working. They can't be shamed but we keep using shame as the only weapon in our arsenal, as if maybe someday it'll kick in and actually hit its mark.

It never seems to occur to us that shunning is the only thing that shuts them up. Just keep an eye on them but leave them alone.

It's no fun to perform if there's no audience worth performing for. They get bored with preaching to their own choir. They want action. They want fireworks. They want fear and dread. Attention is their drug and we keep giving it to them.

Donald Trump would never have become president without the non-stop reporting on his every childish insult, his every deviation from the political norms, his ability to create a circus wherever he went. The media ate it up. The non-stop publicity made him the most unlikely contender in the history of our politics. If he'd been ignored right from the start, if he'd been treated like the ridiculous clown he was when an election season is serious business, he'd still be peddling steaks and bottled water.

Expand full comment

Trump opened the door to ugliness and lawlessness with Tucker and Bannon spreading the lies and venom. They still are.

Expand full comment
author

Trump didn't open the door, he held it wider and invited more in by performing like a carnival barker. Newt Gingrich, the Koch brothers, Sarah Palin, the Tea Party, Ronald Reagan and Richard Nixon got it started. They discovered early on that lying and cheating and elevating their rich donors were all they needed to decimate the poor, the unions, the middle class, and the Democrats.

Expand full comment

You are right! That cycle must be broken now.

Expand full comment
Jan 22Liked by Ramona Grigg

I think we all wish we could do more. Something is so much better than nothing.......

Expand full comment

When we talk about lack of decency perhaps we need to look at our total backslide on values,morality and yes decency. Decency wasn't policed by laws but by people's morals and values, most of which have been lost.

Expand full comment
Mar 26·edited Mar 27

I have seen people who consider themselves decent act with abominable cruelty. Yes, we can attribute this to a complete lack of morals and values.

Expand full comment
Jan 26Liked by Ramona Grigg

I’ve been watching some of the recent US political moves the US government has made, and I wonder how they get away with it. And how the people continue to support them. Closer home, I can see how -- the right-wing majoritarian government in India feeds on the fears of those who feel threatened and downtrodden. They dehumanise the people who they label ‘the others’. And cruelty takes root in the hearts of people who just want to feel ‘safe’. Who don’t realize that ‘the other’ is mostly doing the menial work they never would. It’s so disheartening to watch it unfold, and to know that this is the flavour of the day, that this government will most likely be back in power. We’re seeing, in real time, how decent people let Hitler come into power. By hiding their decency and ceding ground.

Expand full comment
author

Yes, and all we can do is shine light on it. And get out the vote--the logical vote. Thanks.

Expand full comment
Jan 27Liked by Ramona Grigg

Your words are powerful, Ramona. Voices like yours are needed. Thank you for this.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you. Theses are the messages that keep me going. ❤️

Expand full comment
Mar 26·edited Mar 26Liked by Ramona Grigg

Ramona, I have followed your work for a long time. Is there any way I can get in touch with you personally? Kind regards, Olya

Expand full comment
author

Hi Olya, you can email me at ramonagriggwriter at gmail. com

Expand full comment

Thank you. You are always so kind.

Expand full comment